• Coronavirus
  • Blog
  • Careers
  • Contact Us
The Safegard Group, Inc.
  • 1 (888) 892-7688
The Safegard Group, Inc.
  • Client Login
    • Commercial & Personal
    • Employee Benefits
  • Property and Casualty
    • M&A Services
  • Employee Benefits
    • Medical Funding Strategies
    • Technological Capabilities
    • Employee Education
    • Voluntary Benefits
  • Personal Insurance
    • Carrier Claims Reporting

Indalex Case – Case Law Changes – Pennsylvania Faulty Work

04
Apr, 2014
By Apurva Upadhyay, Vice President
  • Property & Casualty,White Papers
  • No comments

Quick Recap:
Kvaerner Metals Div. of Kvaerner U.S., Inc. v. Commercial Union Ins. Co., 908 A.2d 888 (Pa. 2006) (“Kvaerner”):

Deemed that there was no occurrence for two (2) distinct reasons:

  1. Lawsuit alleged breach of warranty and breach of contract
  2. Property damage was limited to the work product itself (defective coke battery) (i.e.: no other property damage)

Millers Capital Ins. Co. v. Gambone Bros. Dev. Co., 941 A.2d 706 (Pa. Super. 2007) (“Gambone“):

Took Kvaerner further by stating that since the work product had faulty workmanship, there was no occurrence to trigger coverage for the resultant property damage (i.e.: water intrusion and mold). The work product was defined as the whole “home” which prevented coverage under the CGL policy.

Additional Reading: Erie Ins. Exchange v. Abbott Furnace Co., 972 A.2d 1232 (Pa. Super. 2009) (“Abbott”)

Indalex, Inc. Background & Decision:
Indalex, Inc., et al, was a manufacturer of windows and doors. Contractors utilizing their products filed lawsuits against Indelex alleging defective products that caused water leakage and physical damage including mold and cracked walls and personal injury. The lawsuits included tort liability, negligence, breach of warrant and breach of contract. The trial court cited Kvaerner, Gambone and Abbott in siding with National Union Fire Insurance Company (“AIG”) determining that there is no occurrence in this situation. The faulty work product and resultant damage did not trigger coverage under the CGL policy.

Indalex, Inc. appealed this decision to the Superior Court which overturned the trial court’s decision and walked a very tight rope in citing its reasons. Each of the above cases (with the exception of “Abbott”) provide the precedent to help policy holders greatly if this decision is upheld (should it reach the PA Supreme Court):

  1. The Kvaerner case was limited to faulty workmanship and property damage to the work product itself (defective coke battery). Since this case had actual property damage, other than the products (windows and doors), the court determined that there was in fact a trigger of coverage (property damage).
  2. The Gambone case defined the work product of Gambone Bros to be the entire home itself. Therefore, the property damage to the homes was determined to be the work product itself and did not constitute an occurrence.
  3. The Abbott case was slightly different, but took Kvaerner further by dictating the allegations of the case to be about breach of contract – it does not, therefore, apply to Indalex.

Conclusions:
We at Safegard have been monitoring the Indalex case since the beginning as the potential ramifications for our manufacturing and construction clients is significant. It’s no secret that Pennsylvania has been notoriously difficult for our clients from a General Liability standpoint because of the far reaching decisions and interpretations of Kvaerner, Gambone & Abbott. The jurisdiction is insurer-friendly and left many customers with no coverage for claims alleging faulty workmanship, regardless of whether the work was done by an insured or a subcontractor.

The decision made by the Superior Court in December of 2013 shows a clear attempt by the courts of Pennsylvania to correct the over-reaching of the current precedents and allows a glimmer of hope to our manufacturing and construction customers in Pennsylvania. We feel that this is a good start to open a dialogue with our insurance companies and brings PA more in line with the rest of the country with regards to coverage for faulty work and resultant damages and most importantly, an insurance company’s duty to defend its customers.

Keep in mind, the allegations of the lawsuit are broad, but the Superior Court has determined that AIG has to defend Indalex, et al, as there are allegations of property damage and strict liability on the insurer’s part. Prior to this decision, insurance companies could cite Kvaerner (and the others) as grounds to deny a claim outright with no defense for our customers (“no occurrence”). With this case, we now have a new tool to fight for our clients and potentially provide defense and investigation costs depending on the claims situation.

Please review the information in this write-up and should you have any questions or require any additional information, do not hesitate to contact Apurva Upadhyay or your assigned Claims Representative at The Safegard Group, Inc. We strive to keep our customers advised of current claims situations and their impact specifically to your operations and exposures.

Apurva Upadhyay, CRIS
Assistant Vice President

Share this:

  • Click to share on Facebook (Opens in new window)
  • Click to share on Twitter (Opens in new window)
  • Click to share on LinkedIn (Opens in new window)
  • Click to print (Opens in new window)

Related

About Apurva Upadhyay, Vice President

Leave a Reply Cancel reply

Categories

  • Claims & Risk Management (141)
  • Company News (73)
    • Designations (2)
    • New Hires (27)
    • Press Release (17)
    • Website (1)
  • Employee Benefits (76)
  • Personal Lines (61)
  • Property & Casualty (154)
  • White Papers (3)
    • Property & Casualty (3)

Recent Posts

  • Gambling in the Workplace December 31, 2019
  • Return to Work Program December 26, 2019
  • The Benefits of Upskilling December 24, 2019
  • Manage Cost of Risk, Control Price December 19, 2019
  • Liability from On-site Fitness Center December 17, 2019

Top Posts

  • Warehouse Housekeeping to Improve Safety
    Warehouse Housekeeping to Improve Safety
  • Amazon Purchases with Your HSA or FSA
    Amazon Purchases with Your HSA or FSA
  • Concrete Truck Safety
    Concrete Truck Safety
  • Health Plan Rules: Treating Employees Differently
    Health Plan Rules: Treating Employees Differently
  • Fueling Safely on the Worksite
    Fueling Safely on the Worksite
  • The 3 S's of Trenching Safely: Slope It, Shore It, Shield It!
    The 3 S's of Trenching Safely: Slope It, Shore It, Shield It!
  • Owners and Contractors Protective Liability
    Owners and Contractors Protective Liability
  • Gambling in the Workplace
    Gambling in the Workplace
  • Return to Work Program
    Return to Work Program
  • The Benefits of Upskilling
    The Benefits of Upskilling
  • @safegardgroup We are proud to share that our own Safety Consultant, Joe Abbonizio was recognized for “Safety Person of the Year”… https://t.co/bbkRCBF4fw by The Safegard Group

    May 11, 2022
  • @safegardgroup We're thrilled to announce we made the Philadelphia Inquirer's 2022 #TopWorkplaces list. This award means the world… https://t.co/yKwTNcERLN by The Safegard Group

    April 19, 2022
  • @safegardgroup We came together to participate in a non-perishable food drive for one of our clients! All donations will benefit f… https://t.co/ISjhO7QAsZ by The Safegard Group

    November 24, 2021
  • @safegardgroup Our Claims Department is looking for a new Claims Consultant, find out more on our website: https://t.co/MNvgnN8tc7 https://t.co/8x8jxcRFWd by The Safegard Group

    August 19, 2021
  • @safegardgroup Our Employee Benefits team is growing! We're currently seeking a new Employee Benefits Account Executive/Manager, f… https://t.co/jRyBjmbgIg by The Safegard Group

    August 19, 2021
  • @safegardgroup We are looking for a full time Commercial Insurance Account Executive/Manager! Find out all of the details and appl… https://t.co/ABUX3Klfzk by The Safegard Group

    August 19, 2021
  • @safegardgroup Job Opening! We are currently recruiting for an entry-level position with our company as an HR Administrator/Execut… https://t.co/gVWuihSKFZ by The Safegard Group

    May 24, 2021
  • @safegardgroup We're hiring! We are looking for a full-time Small Business Account Representative with previous experience in an i… https://t.co/OrP2naH15f by The Safegard Group

    March 5, 2021
  • @safegardgroup Planning to move? Get 30 things to do for 30 days to help make your move easier. https://t.co/pImf1Fj4DU https://t.co/Kl7PLxG5gd by The Safegard Group

    August 7, 2020
  • @safegardgroup Do you know the signs of heat exhaustion? Here are important guidelines to learn how to spot it, prevent it and hel… https://t.co/IHGBWhths8 by The Safegard Group

    August 5, 2020
  • @safegardgroup Increasing your following distance during heavy rain can help keep you safer. Get more safe driving tips:… https://t.co/inKj5IP7lO by The Safegard Group

    August 3, 2020
  • @safegardgroup Use this checklist as a guide when selecting a contractor for your next home renovation. https://t.co/hyLFpwt9Un https://t.co/3konDQs0li by The Safegard Group

    July 31, 2020
  • @safegardgroup Thinking about solar power for your home? Here are a few things to consider before installation:… https://t.co/S2XQAh9VzK by The Safegard Group

    July 29, 2020
  • @safegardgroup Hitting the road this summer? Consider the following tips to help avoid work zones. Share them with your friends an… https://t.co/6kVw4GojnX by The Safegard Group

    July 27, 2020
  • @safegardgroup Moving? Use this three-step packing process from Travelers for a smoother transition to your new home. #ThinkSafe… https://t.co/LhWADcYjX0 by The Safegard Group

    July 24, 2020
  • @safegardgroup Going on vacation? Here are some basic home security steps you can take to help create a secure environment while y… https://t.co/nnSacDWSrk by The Safegard Group

    July 22, 2020
  • @safegardgroup Are you ready to enjoy your time by the pool? Don’t forget the pool safety tips. Share them with your friends & fam… https://t.co/NgwJptoT3M by The Safegard Group

    July 20, 2020
  • @safegardgroup Trying to find the right home inspector? Here are some questions from Travelers to ask potential candidates… https://t.co/r16ZcJDCZA by The Safegard Group

    July 17, 2020
  • @safegardgroup Thunderstorms can strike with little to no warning, bringing dangerous lightning. Do you know how to react if you’r… https://t.co/BbYMxMhjaP by The Safegard Group

    July 15, 2020
  • @safegardgroup Ready to enjoy your fire pit? Read these safety tips to help avoid injury and damage to your home.… https://t.co/LNIZ5n4jKo by The Safegard Group

    July 13, 2020

Subscribe to our Newsletter

By subscribing to our mailing list you will get the latest news from us.

Latest Posts

  • Gambling in the Workplace December 31, 2019
  • Return to Work Program December 26, 2019
  • The Benefits of Upskilling December 24, 2019

Contact

  • The Safegard Group, Inc.
    100 Granite Drive, Suite 205
    Media, PA 19063
  • Phone: 1 (888) 892-7688
    Fax: (610) 892-7695
  • eassistant@safegardgroup.com

Follow Us

© 2020 The Safegard Group, Inc.